These two are almost opposites, which makes the comparison unusually clean.
Craft is a document app with beautiful typography, native Apple design, and sharing built in. Obsidian is a local Markdown editor whose entire premise is that your notes are files on your disk and the app is replaceable.
Both are excellent. They are good at different jobs, and picking the wrong one produces months of low-grade friction.
At a glance
| Craft | Obsidian | |
|---|---|---|
| Storage | Craft's cloud, proprietary format | Plain Markdown files on your disk |
| Editing | Block editor, WYSIWYG, very polished | Markdown, live preview or source |
| Look | Exceptional out of the box | Plain, until you theme it |
| Sharing | Publish a page as a link, genuinely good | Possible, but not the point |
| Extensibility | Limited | Thousands of community plugins |
| Linking | Backlinks, page nesting | Backlinks, graph, transclusion, queries |
| Offline | Yes | Yes, it is local by default |
| Mobile | Strong, native feel | Functional, less polished |
| Price | Subscription for full use | Free for personal use, paid sync and publish |
| Portability | Export available, format is theirs | Your notes are already portable |
The case for Craft
Documents that look finished. Craft output is presentable without effort. If your notes leave your head and go to a client, a team, or a public link, this is not a superficial advantage. Obsidian can be made to look good; Craft is good-looking by default.
Blocks that behave. Every block is addressable and can be linked to individually. Nested pages inside documents work well, which suits people who think in outlines and documents rather than atomic units.
It is pleasant. This matters more than tool-comparison articles usually admit. An app you enjoy opening gets opened, and a note-taking system that you avoid produces nothing regardless of its architecture.
Sharing and collaboration are first-class. Sending a link to a nicely formatted page is a two-second operation.
The case for Obsidian
Your notes are files. This is the whole argument and it is a strong one. Markdown in folders means every backup tool, sync service, script, and future app can read them. Nothing about your archive depends on the company continuing to exist. See file over app and plain text notes.
Plugins. Spaced repetition, kanban, Dataview queries, citation integration, calendars. Whatever workflow you want probably exists. This also means Obsidian can become a mess of half-configured plugins, which is the standard failure mode.
Linking as a system, not a feature. Backlinks, unlinked mentions, transclusion, and the graph together make it a genuine Zettelkasten environment rather than a document store with links added.
Local and free. No account required, works offline permanently, and free for personal use.
The trade-off in one paragraph
Craft optimises the experience of writing and sharing a document. Obsidian optimises the durability and connectedness of a collection. If your unit of work is "a document someone will read," Craft. If your unit of work is "a note that will connect to other notes for years," Obsidian.
Notice that this maps onto atomic notes versus long-form documents, which is a real difference in how people think, not a difference in taste.
Where each one hurts
Craft's format is Craft's. Export exists and is not the same as your notes being portable. Links, nesting, and blocks do not survive a migration cleanly. For a few hundred documents this is manageable. For a decade of accumulated thinking it is the thing you should think hardest about.
Craft is a subscription for anything serious, and the archive lives in their cloud.
Obsidian is plain. Out of the box it looks like a text editor, because it is one. Some people find this focusing and some find it dispiriting, and neither reaction is wrong.
Obsidian's mobile app is fine, not delightful. If most of your capture happens on a phone in the queue for coffee, this matters daily. See how to capture a note for why capture friction dominates everything else.
Obsidian's sync is a decision. Paid official sync, iCloud, or a third-party service, each with its own conflict behaviour. See syncing notes across devices.
Obsidian invites tinkering. A meaningful number of users spend more time configuring the system than using it. PKM mistakes has the full list.
Using both, which is common and sensible
There is no rule against a split. Obsidian as the archive, Craft for documents that leave the building. The overhead is one decision per note, and the decision is easy: does anyone else read this?
If that sounds like too much, the tiebreaker is time horizon. Ask how much you would mind losing everything you write in the next five years. The more the answer is "a great deal," the more the file format matters and the more the answer is Obsidian.
More in Obsidian vs Notion, Craft vs Notion, Craft vs Bear, and note app comparisons.