Ulysses vs Scrivener: A Calm Library or a Research Workshop

Both are serious long-form writing tools with devoted users, and they disagree about what the hard part of writing is. (Disclosure: we make a notes app, Clair Mind. Referee only.)

Ulysses says the hard part is showing up. So it removes everything: one library, markdown, no formatting decisions, no windows, no chrome.

Scrivener says the hard part is structure. So it gives you a binder, a corkboard, index cards, a research folder, split views and a compile engine.

Neither is wrong. They describe different books and different writers.

At a glance

Ulysses Scrivener
Model One library of sheets, filterable One project file per book, with a binder
Format Markdown Rich text, with its own project structure
Research Weak — some attachments Strong — PDFs, images, web pages inside the project
Restructuring Drag sheets Corkboard, outliner, purpose-built
Export Excellent, style-based Excellent, extremely configurable (Compile)
Platforms Apple only Mac, Windows, iOS
Price Subscription One-time purchase, per platform
Feels like A clean desk A workshop

Where Ulysses wins

Daily writing. The single-library model means everything you write lives in one place — blog posts, chapters, journal entries, notes — filterable by tags rather than filed into project silos. Open it and write; there is no project to create first, which sounds trivial and matters enormously for a daily habit.

It gets out of the way. Markdown means no formatting decisions while drafting, and styling happens at export. For anyone who has lost twenty minutes to fonts, this is the point.

Goals and typewriter mode support the actual discipline of finishing drafts.

Publishing. Direct export to WordPress, Ghost and Medium is genuinely convenient for people who write for the web.

The costs: it is a subscription, it is Apple-only, and — the real limit — it is weak at research and at restructuring anything complex. Reordering forty sheets by dragging is worse than a corkboard, and there is nowhere good to keep the interview transcripts and PDFs a serious non-fiction project needs.

Where Scrivener wins

Long, structured, research-heavy work. A novel with twelve viewpoint characters, or a non-fiction book resting on 200 sources. The binder holds the manuscript and the research in one project, so the source sits next to the chapter that uses it.

Restructuring. The corkboard and outliner exist because reordering a 100,000-word manuscript is a real task that a flat list handles badly. Synopsis cards you can shuffle, with the text attached, is the feature nothing else replicates properly.

Compile. Unmatched control over turning one manuscript into a paperback PDF, an ebook, a Word file for an editor, and a plain manuscript for submission. Configurable to a fault.

One-time purchase, and it runs on Windows — both of which matter for a tool you may use for a decade.

Its costs are equally famous. The learning curve is steep and genuinely puts people off; there is a tutorial you should actually do. It is heavier to open, which quietly discourages ten-minute sessions. And the project-file model means your writing is siloed per book rather than in one library.

The question that decides it

Is your problem the habit, or the structure?

If you struggle to write regularly and your projects are essays, articles and posts — Ulysses. Its whole design is aimed at reducing the cost of starting.

If you are assembling something long from many parts and sources, and you will restructure it repeatedly — Scrivener. Ulysses will not cope, and you will blame yourself for a tool mismatch.

Second tiebreaker: do you need Windows? Scrivener, by default.

Neither is a notes app

This is worth stating because writers routinely try to make one of these hold everything.

Both are manuscript tools. Scrivener's research folder is for material relevant to this project, and when the book is done that project file gets archived and its knowledge leaves with it. Neither builds a connected body of thinking across years, neither has meaningful links between ideas, and neither is reachable when a line of dialogue occurs to you in a supermarket.

Writers generally end up with three layers, and being deliberate about it helps:

  1. Capture — a fast phone app for the idea, the line, the overheard phrase.
  2. A permanent notes archive — ideas, research, patterns, connected across projects. See evergreen notes and writing from your notes.
  3. A manuscript tool — Ulysses or Scrivener, for the draft.

The layer most writers are missing is the second, which is why every book starts from scratch. The layer that fails most often is the first, because ideas arrive away from the desk and forgetting starts within seconds. That is the gap Clair Mind is built for.

The third option

If your writing is mostly short and you already keep notes in markdown, Obsidian with a long-form plugin covers a surprising amount of this for free, with files you own — see plain text notes. It is worse at compiling a book and better at everything before that.

Related: Bear vs Obsidian, best notes app for writers, and the wider note app comparisons.

More in App Comparisons

78 more notes on this branch.

Clair Mind connects your own notes exactly like this — automatically, privately, on your iPhone. Get the app →