Todoist vs Things: Everywhere and Rented, or Apple-Only and Owned

Task managers are adjacent to notes rather than the same thing, but the comparison belongs here because most people's tasks and notes leak into each other constantly, and the decision has the same shape. (Disclosure: we make a notes app, Clair Mind. Referee only.)

The short version: Things is the better-crafted app and it only runs on Apple devices, for a one-time purchase per platform. Todoist runs everywhere on a subscription. For most people that settles it before design preference is consulted.

At a glance

Things Todoist
Platforms Apple only — Mac, iPhone, iPad, Watch Everywhere, including web and Windows
Price One-time purchase, per platform Free tier; subscription for most useful features
Model GTD-flavoured: Inbox, Today, Upcoming, Areas, Projects Projects, labels, filters, priorities
Capture Excellent — global quick entry Excellent — natural language parsing
Collaboration None Yes, shared projects
Integrations Few Many
Feel Calm, opinionated, quiet Flexible, busier

Where Things wins

Design that reduces anxiety. This sounds like a soft criterion and it is the main one people cite after a year. Things is quiet — it does not badge you, gamify you, or present your day as a wall of overdue red. The Today view shows what you chose for today, and that restraint changes how it feels to open, which changes whether you open it.

The structure is opinionated and correct. Inbox for capture, Areas for ongoing responsibilities, Projects for things that end, Someday for the rest. It is a well-implemented reading of Getting Things Done, and it makes the right thing easy without requiring you to design a system.

You buy it once. In a market that has moved almost entirely to subscriptions, a one-time purchase is worth something — even paying separately for Mac and iOS.

Its costs are non-negotiable: Apple only, no collaboration whatsoever, and few integrations. If your household or team coordinates a shared list, Things cannot do it at all.

Where Todoist wins

It runs where you are. Windows at work, Android phone, a Linux box, a browser on someone else's machine. For anyone not fully inside Apple's world this is the entire argument and nothing else needs saying.

Natural language capture. "Pay invoice every 2nd Tuesday p1 #finance" parses into a recurring, prioritised, labelled task in one line. It is the fastest capture in the category and it is genuinely habit-forming.

Sharing. Shared projects for a household, a team, a partner. Things has no answer here.

Filters and integrations. Custom filter queries are powerful, and it connects to nearly everything.

The costs: it is a subscription, and meaningful features sit behind it. The interface is busier and more configurable, which invites tinkering. And features like karma and streaks motivate some people and make others feel nagged by their own to-do list.

The question that decides it

  1. Do you use any non-Apple device? → Todoist. Done.
  2. Do you need to share lists? → Todoist.
  3. Neither? → Things, most likely, on design and the one-time price.

Genuinely, that is the decision tree. Both are excellent at the core job; the constraints do the choosing.

The part people get wrong

Tasks and notes are different objects, and merging them is the most common cause of both systems failing.

A task is a commitment with a next action and, usually, a time. A note is thinking. Putting "think about the Q3 strategy" in a task manager produces something that is never done and slowly poisons the list, because a list full of undone items stops being trusted — and an untrusted list stops releasing the mental load that is the whole reason to keep one.

The clean division:

  • Task manager: things with a next action. Short text. Nothing else.
  • Notes: the thinking, the reasoning, the reference material.
  • Link between them when a task needs context.

This is also why Apple Notes vs Reminders is a more consequential comparison than it looks — the same confusion, one layer down.

Where a notes app fits

Neither of these is where an idea should land. A thought arriving mid-walk is usually not yet a task; forcing it into a task manager means either mangling it into an action it is not, or losing it.

Capture first, decide later. That is what Clair Mind does — one gesture, no structure demanded, and the things that turn out to be commitments can move to Things or Todoist during a review. See the note inbox and the weekly review.

Related: Apple Notes vs Reminders, Notion vs Trello, and the wider note app comparisons.

More in App Comparisons

78 more notes on this branch.

Clair Mind connects your own notes exactly like this — automatically, privately, on your iPhone. Get the app →