This is an unusual comparison because the two apps barely overlap. People arrive at it after using Keep for years, accumulating several hundred notes, and hitting the wall where it stops being findable. Obsidian is the tool they are told to move to, and the move frequently fails. (Disclosure: we make a notes app, Clair Mind. Referee only.)
Understanding why it fails is more useful than the feature table.
At a glance
| Google Keep | Obsidian | |
|---|---|---|
| Time to capture a thought | ~2 seconds | ~10–20 seconds on mobile |
| Organisation | Labels and colours | Folders, links, backlinks, properties, Bases |
| Storage | Google's cloud | Markdown files on your disk |
| Links between notes | None | The core feature |
| Search | Good, fast, fuzzy | Good, and stronger at scale |
| Sync | Automatic, free | Paid Obsidian Sync, or your own setup |
| Price | Free | Free for personal use; Sync/Publish paid |
| Ceiling | Low — breaks down in the hundreds | Very high |
| Floor | Anyone, immediately | Requires setup and intent |
What Keep is genuinely excellent at
Speed. Widget on the home screen, tap, type, done. No file, no folder, no title, no decision. On Android it is close to the fastest capture available, and that matters more than its feature list suggests, because capture is where most systems actually fail.
Its search is also better than its structure deserves — fuzzy, fast, and forgiving of badly written notes, which is most notes.
Where it ends is equally clear. There are no folders, no links, no hierarchy and no way to build anything. Labels and colours work for perhaps two hundred notes and then flatten into noise. Nothing accumulates: Keep holds a pile, and a pile does not become knowledge no matter how large it gets.
What Obsidian is genuinely excellent at
Everything Keep is not. Markdown files you own outright, links and backlinks so ideas connect, and a structure that stays navigable at ten thousand notes. It is the right tool for building a body of thinking over years — see Zettelkasten and plain text notes.
Where it fails is the thing Keep does best. On mobile, opening Obsidian, waiting for the vault, creating a note, and deciding where it goes is enough friction that thoughts get lost. Sync is your problem or a subscription. And the configurability is a documented sink — people spend weekends on plugins and folder schemes and write nothing. See PKM mistakes.
Why the migration usually fails
The move from Keep to Obsidian is presented as an upgrade, and structurally it is a trade: you gain organisation and lose capture speed.
If capture speed was the reason your Keep filled up in the first place — and it usually was — then removing it means the new vault stays empty. Two months later there are forty notes in a beautifully configured Obsidian setup and the real thinking has quietly migrated back to Keep, or to nothing.
The second failure is importing everything. Six hundred unstructured Keep notes dumped into a vault produce six hundred unstructured markdown files, plus the disappointment of realising that structure is something you have to build rather than something the app supplies.
The setup that actually works
Do not migrate. Layer.
- Keep captures. Anything, instantly, unfiled. It is the inbox.
- Obsidian keeps. Once a week, move the handful worth keeping into the vault, rewritten in your own words and linked to something.
- Empty Keep as you go. It should hover near empty, not accumulate.
This respects the fact that capture and organisation pull against each other — capture wants zero structure, an archive wants some. Very few single apps do both well, which is why the two-layer pattern keeps reappearing. See the note inbox and the weekly review.
The honest expectation: maybe one note in ten survives to the vault. That ratio is correct, not a failure.
Choose Keep alone if
- Your notes are lists, reminders and short-lived fragments.
- You have a few hundred notes and no ambition to connect them.
- You want free, zero setup, and nothing to maintain.
- You are on Android, where its capture is at its best.
Choose Obsidian alone if
- You are building an archive meant to last years.
- Your value is in links between your own ideas.
- You want files you own, and you accept solving sync.
- You mostly write at a desk, where its capture cost does not bite.
Choose both if
You are the person this comparison is written for: Keep is full, unfindable, and you want something better without losing the thing that made you use Keep.
The third option
The two-app split works and it has a real cost — you have to remember to empty one into the other, and that habit is the first thing to lapse.
The alternative is a tool designed so capture is Keep-fast and connections get drawn without you filing anything. That is what Clair Mind is built around: one gesture in, no folder decision, and the relationships between notes surfaced rather than maintained by hand.
Related: Google Keep vs OneNote, Apple Notes vs Google Keep, Anytype vs Obsidian, and the wider note app comparisons.